Carmen

Posted:

Read our review of Carmen here.

Le French May brings Bizet’s classic opera closer to Hong Kong, writes William Lane

The romantic allure of Seville, a beautiful gypsy and a sizzling plot of love, seduction, betrayal and murder. With all these elements, not to mention the bullfighters and smugglers, it’s hardly surprising that Carmen remains one of the world’s most popular operas almost 150 years after its penning. Indeed, it’s timeless. But with such a well-loved work, so comes a different challenge: how to bring it to life in a distinctive way.

For the Le French May production of Georges Bizet’s opera, this responsibility lies with legendary French director Philippe Arlaud, someone who is well-versed in the nuances of Carmen. He directed the opera in Baden-Baden, Germany, in 2010, but, as he explains, that production differed significantly from what he stages in Hong Kong this fortnight. “I try to find a dialectic between a work and a city, a theatre tradition and a modern public,” says Arlaud. “That means I would not do the same Carmen in Paris, Seville, Tokyo, Santa Fe or Hong Kong. The new opera is a sum of reciprocal influences through time and space.”

In Hong Kong, all these factors translate into an aesthetically vibrant, seductively skewed creation featuring an international, star-studded cast including Israeli-born mezzo-soprano Rinat Shaham in the role of Carmen, French tenor Jean-Pierre Furlan as Don Jose as well as the Shanghai Opera House Orchestra, conducted by Benjamin Pionnier. “The production in Baden-Baden was built around the vision
of Don Jose in the book as Merimee, with a process of flashback,” says Arlaud. “In Hong Kong, the production will be more linear
and follow the libretto by Meilhac and Halevy. It will be more colourful. The acting is more sensual and more raw, erotic and cruel.”
Apart from his directorial role, Arlaud also takes on the roles of stage, set and lighting designer. “Like many of my colleagues, Wernicke, Ponnelle, Wilson, Freyer, Herrmann to name a few, I work as arranger and writer, and I bring together technology, the arts, people, tastes in order of opera performance – a total art,” he says. Perhaps the most unique element of this production is Arlaud’s modern set design.

He uses a revolving stage and sets ‘an elliptical wall above a circle’ that allows countless combinations to correspond to the different scenes, paving the way for super-fast set changes. “I do not use the revolving stage in a traditional way – ie two or three sets on a cheese platter,” says the director. “I use it primarily in conjunction with the music and it allows me to get zoom effects, expansion or shrinkage of space framing and scenic effects.”

Arlaud has also envisioned a vibrant aesthetic palette for the production. As opposed to his very ‘black and white’ conception in the Baden-Baden production, the Le French May Carmen sees the daylight world (acts one and four) showered in a rich ochre and red hue, while the world of the night (acts two and three) take on a metallic and mineral blue and grey atmosphere.

Ultimately, Arlaud is hoping a message shines through. “[This production of Carmen] represents risks, challenges, commitments and happiness, to come here to defend the idea of freedom so dear to the French!” he says. “It is painful to kill Carmen, probably because we are also afraid to kill the libeté that is within us.” 

Read our review of Carmen here.

 

Tags:

4 Comments Add your comment

  • This was probably the worst opera production that I have seen. Either the director has a deep-seated contempt both for Bizet and for the audience, or he's simply incompetent. The soloists were capable, and the Shanghai Opera House Orchestra was fantastic, but nothing could save this production from the farcical direction, appalling choreography, and infantile set design. Hugely disappointing.

    Posted by David on May 14, 2012 at 09:14 AM
  • I also attended, and have to agree. This production reminded me of a pantomime. OHK productions are usually much better. The slapstick comedy was particularly jarring, and the backdrops were apparently borrowed from a school play. Art is subjective, but if half the audience laughs during your death scene (as they did on Saturday night), it's a good indicator you're doing it wrong.

    Posted by Peter on May 14, 2012 at 09:24 AM
  • After reading the interview with Philippe Arlaud, I can't help but feel that this production is a huge insult to Hong Kong and Shanghai. He claimed “I try to find a dialectic between a work and a city, a theatre tradition and a modern public...” What really came across is that Arlaud has absolutely no idea of what Hong Kong is and therefore was in no position to actually form any sort of dialectic, except between himself and the work.

    Posted by Manzi on May 15, 2012 at 03:00 AM
  • the Shanghai opera orchestra was a joke. What were you listening to? The woodwinds where out of tune. Only the oboe and clarinet were good. The flutes out of tune most the time. The French horns were gurgling all through their critical 3rd act. Style from the brass in the 4th act entre'act was all wrong. Strings sounded like they were playing cheap instruments. Usually a Carmen orchestra overpowers the singers at times, but this one never came close (a blessing). But this is why the red curtain by the conductor was down. I saw too many players in the pit, but they needed the curtain down to make more sound. There were only a few instances with any symphonic sound at all from the pit. This is besides all the problems with sets and action. This was an insult to hong kong on many levels.

    Posted by merlin on May 19, 2012 at 05:02 PM

Add your comment

Time Out Hong Kong reserves the right to remove or edit comments that are potentially defamatory or offensive.